Reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you buy through our links. We don’t test products hands-on; we analyze labels, lab certifications and research. How we rate

How we rate products

We don’t test products hands-on. We check what can be checked: the label against the research, independent lab certifications, safety records and the real cost of an effective dose. Every product in a category is scored the same way, with rules we publish before we score anything.

Last updated

What a Lab Score is

Every product gets five scores from 0 to 10. The Lab Score is their weighted average, rounded to one decimal.

Lab ScoreWhat it means
9.0 to 10Excellent
8.0 to 8.9Very good
7.0 to 7.9Good
5.0 to 6.9Fair
Under 5.0Poor

No product scoring under 7.0 can be one of our picks. A score is only published when all five checks are documented, each with a source and a date.

Supplements: the five checks

CheckWhat we look atWeight
Dose vs researchThe daily amount of each headline ingredient, following the label’s directions, compared with the range used in human studies. For creatine, that is 3 to 5 g of creatine monohydrate a day. Other forms, such as creatine HCl, are compared on their actual creatine content.30%
Third-party testingWe look the product up in the certifier’s own database. A logo on the tub isn’t enough. Scores by program are listed below.25%
Cost per effective doseThe price of one research-backed dose, compared with the median of every product we track in the category: 7 points at the median, 4 points fewer each time the price doubles, between 0 and 10.20%
Label transparencyEvery dose disclosed, no proprietary blends (4 points), the exact form of each ingredient (1), a public certificate of analysis (2), a named supplier (1), and no disease claims (2).15%
Safety recordFDA warning letters and recalls in the last five years, plus contamination recalls anywhere in the brand in the last two years. Points off are listed below.10%

Safety record: points off

SignalCounts forPoints off
FDA warning letter to the maker or brand about manufacturing or adulteration, closed5 years−4
Recall of this product, Class II or III, resolved5 years−4
FDA warning letter about disease claims5 years−2
Missing safety warning on the labelUntil fixed−2
Recall of another product by the same brand for contamination (pathogens, heavy metals, hidden drugs, foreign material)2 years−2

The score starts at 10 and never goes below 0. Serious cases, such as a Class I recall, aren’t scored: the product can’t be recommended at all (see below).

Third-party testing scores

ProgramScreens for banned substancesScore
NSF Certified for SportYes10
Informed SportYes10
USP VerifiedNo9
NSF Contents Certified (NSF/ANSI 173)No9
Informed ChoiceYes7
Published ISO 17025 certificate of analysisNo6
In-house or on-request certificateNo3
No third-party testing found—0

When a brand claims a certification we haven’t found in the certifier’s database yet, the product is scored with the claimed program but marked provisional, and it can’t be a pick until we confirm it.

Wearables and health tech: the five checks

CheckWhat we look atWeight
Independent validationPublished studies comparing the device with a reference method, such as a sleep lab or an ECG, by researchers with no tie to the brand.30%
Cost over two yearsThe device price plus 24 months of the membership you need to use the features we score.25%
FeaturesA checklist set for each category before we score the first device.20%
Compatibility and dataiOS and Android, Apple Health and Health Connect sync, raw data export, core data without a subscription.15%
Warranty and returnsWarranty length, return window, free sizing or size exchange.10%

Smart rings: the checklists

Features (score = 10 × the share present): Sleep stages, Heart rate variability (HRV), Skin temperature, Blood oxygen (SpO2), Activity and workout tracking, Menstrual cycle tracking, Battery of 5 days or more (claimed), Water resistance for swimming.

Compatibility and data: works with iphone and android (3 points), syncs with apple health and health connect (3 points), raw data export (file or api) for owners (2 points), core data available without a subscription (2 points).

Warranty and returns: a warranty of two years or more (5 points; one year, 3), change-of-mind returns for 30 days or more (3 points; 14 to 29 days, 1), and a free sizing kit (2 points).

Each answer comes from the brand’s own pages or a named source. When a brand doesn’t state something clearly, the ring shows “Not rated yet” rather than a guessed score. A study counts as independent only once we have read its conflict-of-interest statement; until then, the score is provisional.

Recovery and home equipment: the five checks

CheckWhat we look atWeight
Verified specsThe two or three numbers that matter, such as irradiance for red light or minimum temperature for a cold plunge, measured by an independent lab or tester.30%
Safety certificationA full-product listing by a recognized lab such as UL, Intertek (ETL) or CSA.20%
Cost over two yearsPrice plus required consumables and delivery or installation.20%
Warranty and supportWarranty length, US-based support, spare parts.20%
FeaturesA checklist set for each category before we score the first product.10%

What keeps a product out

  • Never covered: peptides, SARMs and prohormones, prescription drugs, “research chemicals,” and any product on the FDA’s list of tainted supplements or the USADA High Risk List.
  • Never recommended: products with a Class I recall, an FDA warning letter about manufacturing or adulteration in the last 24 months with no closeout, a dose above the official safe upper limit, a certification claim we can’t find in the certifier’s database, or a mains-powered device used with water and no safety certification. These products can appear in our tables with the reason, never as a pick and never with an affiliate link.

How we choose our picks

  • Best overall is the highest Lab Score among products that pass every check and hold a lab certification we verified ourselves.
  • Best budget is the lowest cost per effective dose among products scoring at least 7.5 with verified testing. When our best overall pick is already the cheapest of these, we say so and don’t name a separate budget pick, because it would cost you more.
  • Best premium needs a score of at least 8.5, a cost above the median, and an advantage we can verify, such as a named premium ingredient source.
  • A pick must deliver at least the dose used in research when you follow its own label.
  • Each product can win one pick at most, and a guide names 5 picks at most. Ties are broken by testing, then by price. Never by commission.
  • When we can’t yet verify a certification ourselves, the score is marked “provisional” and the product can’t be a pick.

Where our data comes from

DataSourceHow often we check
Safety alertsFDA warning letters and recallsWeekly
CertificationsNSF, Informed Sport, Informed Choice and USP databasesMonthly
Prices shown on the pageMajor US retailers; Amazon prices come from Amazon’s own data and show the date and timeDaily for Amazon, weekly for other stores
Prices used in scoresThe same retailers: a named store, observed no more than 90 days before the check dateMonthly, so scores don’t swing with daily deals
LabelsBrand sites and retailer label photosEvery six months, or when a formula changes
Research dosesScientific position stands, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, meta-analysesYearly
Device validationPeer-reviewed studiesEvery six months

Every number on BeAlphaLab carries its source and the date we checked it.

Which store we link to first

The main “Check price” button goes to the cheapest store that has the product in stock. Another store may go first only when it is within both 3% and $1 of the cheapest price, and pays us more. On a $30 tub, that means 90 cents at most. The cheapest price always stays listed on the page.

How our pages are made

We use software, including AI tools, to collect data and draft pages. Every page is checked against its sources and approved by our editor before it goes live. We don’t have a medical reviewer yet: here is how we handle health content until we do. Scores come from the method on this page, computed the same way for every product.

What we don’t do

  • Hands-on testing or “I tried it” claims
  • Our own lab analysis of products
  • Paid placements, paid reviews or paid scores
  • Personal medical advice

Method changelog

This page describes method version 1.2, published Oct 22, 2026.

Version 1.2, Oct 22, 2026. Two rules added after checking FDA records for every brand we rate, where we found a contamination recall of another product at one brand:

  • A recall of any product by the same brand for contamination (pathogens, heavy metals, hidden drugs, foreign material) costs 2 safety points for 24 months.
  • A product below the research dose, following its own label, can’t be a pick.

We rescored every creatine the same day. The first rule moved BulkSupplements from 9.6 to 9.4 and from “Best overall” to “Best budget”; Sports Research became “Best overall”.

Version 1.1, Oct 22, 2026. Clarifications after scoring our first category:

  • Dose is the daily amount following the label’s directions, without a loading phase.
  • Different forms of an ingredient are compared on the amount of the active compound they deliver (creatine HCl on its creatine content).
  • NSF Contents Certified (NSF/ANSI 173) added to the testing programs, scored 9.
  • Each product can win one pick at most.
  • A certification we haven’t confirmed in the certifier’s database makes the score provisional.
  • Until we track prices daily, scores use the lowest price observed on the check date, from a named store, no more than 90 days old.
  • No separate budget pick when the best overall pick is already the cheapest qualifying product.
  • A better-paying store may go first only within both 3% and $1 of the cheapest price.

Version 1.0, Oct 22, 2026. First version, written before any product was scored. Every change is listed here, and all scores in the category are recalculated the same day.